Bruno Mars’ “Happy” and Miley’s “We Can’t Stop”: A Case of Musical Similarity
Miley Cyrus Faces Lawsuit Over Plagiarism Allegations: Bruno Mars’ “Happy” and Miley’s “We Can’t Stop” Under Scrutiny
Cyrus’ “We Can’t Stop” has been the subject of a copyright infringement lawsuit that alleges that she copied portions of the song from Mars’ hit single, "Happy".
The lawsuit was filed in 2018 by songwriter Franki Prevot, who claims that the chorus of “We Can’t Stop” is “substantially similar” to the chorus of “Happy”.
Prevot’s lawsuit alleges that Cyrus and her collaborators had access to “Happy” before they wrote “We Can’t Stop”.
Allegations of Plagiarism and Musical Similarity
The lawsuit’s arguments hinge on the similarities between the choruses of the two songs. Both songs feature a repetitive, upbeat melody with lyrics that exude a sense of joy and freedom.
Experts in music theory have analyzed both songs and found striking similarities in their melodic structure, harmonic progressions, and rhythmic patterns.
However, it's important to note that these similarities alone do not definitively prove plagiarism. The court will need to consider various factors, including the originality of the allegedly infringed material and the intent of the accused.
Cyrus and Mars Respond to the Lawsuit
Both Cyrus and Mars have denied the allegations of plagiarism.
Cyrus’ lawyer has stated that the “We Can’t Stop” chorus was created independently and that there was no intentional copying of “Happy”.
Mars has also denied any wrongdoing. His lawyer has argued that the similarities between the two songs are due to the use of common musical elements.
Legal Proceedings and Potential Outcomes
The lawsuit is currently ongoing, and it remains to be seen how the court will rule.
If Prevot is successful in proving plagiarism, Cyrus could face significant consequences, including financial damages, a loss of reputation, and damage to her career.
Alternatively, if Cyrus and Mars are able to successfully defend against the allegations, the lawsuit could be dismissed, and both artists could continue their careers without further legal challenges.
Conclusion
The lawsuit between Franki Prevot and Miley Cyrus over the alleged plagiarism of Bruno Mars’ “Happy” highlights the complex issue of musical similarity in the entertainment industry.
The outcome of this case could have a significant impact on the way that artists approach songwriting and the use of existing musical ideas.
Comments